Positional Panic Primer
August 25th, 2009 by LvilleOrangeWell we are progressing quite nicely to the start of this season. As of this writing we are just 11 days away from the home opener versus Minnesota! And after reading a few of Brian Bennett’s Big East position rankings, it’s clear we suck, really suck. And I’ll boldy predict how we will fair with the rest of the ratings, we will suck, suck and suck some more. Speaking of “giant sucking sounds”, here’s our poster boy from 1992 – H Ross Perot (I just love those charts!)
So while sadly the world of pundits would like to move quickly to Florida vs USC, the rest of us that actually want to see some games have to figure out something to do in the meantime. I figured it was time to look at our various positions and rank them from least concerning to most pressing heading into the season.
1. Running back. Such is the life of the Syracuse Orangemen fan that we list a position of least concern as one that must replace a 1000 yard rusher. Yes Curtis Brinkley, last season’s workhorse is gone, but he as left the position in the great hands or should I say “tremendous biceps” of Delone Carter. Carter has had a great camp and is looking to return to the promise of his freshman campaign where he rushed for over 700 yards. Joining Carter is Antwon Bailey, last year’s hero in the Notre Dame game. These two will garner the majority of the carries and they have fellow runners Averin Collier and Mike Jones behind them. Jones has even caught the eye of Coach Marrone and will likely be a kick returner this season. On a scale from one to ten, I rate my concern for this unit a one.
2. Punting . Junior Rob Long entered the program two years ago and has handled the punting duties like a seasoned veteran, demonstrating a strong durable leg. Now an actual veteran, he is listed in many circles as a possible first team All BE kicker. If he needs to work on anything, it is his ability to place kicks inside the 20. All in all, this is not an area of concern in my mind, I give it a .5 rating.
3. WRs. Ok here is where the rankings start to get interesting. Coach Marrone has been imploring the overall unit to produce a worthy #2 to compliment Mike Williams. Alec Lemon has shown promise, but he’s a true frosh. Donte Davis, Marcus Sales, Da’Mon Merkerson, Van Chew and Lavar Lobdell are all in the mix. Still when I evaluate our team, at least we have Mike Williams. Look how lost we were last season with NO go to receiver. I know things will have to get better, but at least we got Mike. So on the concern o meter, give this one a 2.
4. CB/S. An area of concern in the spring has quietly looked like it has been upgraded this fall. Mike Holmes is turning heads at Safety. Max Suter is the other safety and he played well as the nickel against spread teams last year. Nico and Kevyn Scott are holding their own at corner. Yes the loss of Dorian Graham is a concern, but it sounds like we have some playmakers in Philip Thomas, Shamarko Thomas and Rishard Anderson who all look like they will see the field. If they all must be pressed into action then it will be an issue, but right now the top 4 seem to be set. On the concern o meter, I put this unit at 5.
5. Coaching staff – yeah I went ahead and listed the staff here, because ultimately it will be the coaches whose game management will be key to whatever success we have this season. So far there is reason for optimism, but the reality is that DM has no head coaching experience. It remains to be seen if the staff will have any issues like getting plays called in a timely manner or have trouble in making adjustments. I think we are all anxious to see what kind of product we get. On my concern level, I’d put it at a 4.5.
On to the real big problems after the jump…







Well I was dangerously close to blowing off UConn, but I felt this immense sense of guilt and so I figured I might as well do this thing. So let’s get right at it.
As we inch ever closer to the start of fall practice, its time to finish off the “off season” opponent previews before they become “in season” previews. So let’s get to today’s look in – Rutgers.
Ok, the Big East Media Day is now in the rear view mirror. If you train your eye around the league, the prevailing theme was this – We got dissed! Whether it was coaches, players or the commissioner, in some form or fashion everyone was slighted. You think I’m kidding? It’s like shooting fish in a barrel to get quotes from the downtrodden. Hell here at CuseOrange and for most of Cuse Nation, the day was upstaged by the
#1 Pittsburgh – The Panthers here really? Yes, really. I have to convince myself of this even as I type this. I really like their defense and they just need Bill Stull to be serviceable. The schedule favors them as well, as Cincy and USF must travel to Pitt. Toughest road test will be at Rutgers; they’ve already proven to be able to go to Morgantown and that game will be a war.
#2 Cincinnati – Last year’s champs were picked 5th in the media poll
#3 South Florida – Matt Grothe’s final run will give the Bulls a chance to run at the title. What may hold them back is their offensive line. Defense will not be an issue either with George Selvie leading the front 4. Still landmine games at Pitt, Rutgers and even UConn in December will make a title run difficult.
#4 Rutgers – Now here is a team with a favorable schedule. Their road games are UConn, Syracuse and Louisville, likely the bottom 3 teams in the league. The problem is that we have no idea who is running the show. Domenic Natale looks the Day One starter (unless Tom Savage really excels once camp opens), but Day One is against Cincy and that could be a problem. Still they have a stellar line and a good chunk of defense returning. Some sites have reached for Rutgers to win. I’m tepid at this point, but they have a real shot.
#5 West Virginia – I know that some ‘eer fans will be screaming over this. But not since Tee Martin and the Volunteers has a team lost a qb with the stature of Pat White and gotten better. Jarrett Brown does have experience and the defense will be formidable, but in the end the final 3 games at Cincy, home to Pitt, and at Rutgers could end 0-3. And if the Oline struggles with some of these top defenses like USF and Pitt, a 3-4 conference mark is possible.
#6 Connecticut - Replacing First team AA Donald Brown and QB Tyler Lorenzen will be key to the Huskies season. They will have a great defense led by the best LB unit in the BE. Still road games against Pitt, WV and Cincy is not the recipe for challenging in Big East this season. Throw in some tough OOC games vs NC, Baylor and ND and this team may struggle to reach .500.
#7 Syracuse - Doug Marrone has his hands full in season one. First off is the QB spot where Redshirt frosh Ryan Nassib will be pressed by Greg Paulus. Mike Williams return will help the passing game. The deck chairs were shuffled a bit at LB. And while the schedule sets up nicely, this team will be more concerned with leaving the triple digits in offensive and defensive rankings versus securing Ws. Look for improved play, but a lot of work to do.
#8 Louisville – The Cards appear to be in real trouble. No QB was named starter out of spring, how long before Steve Kragthorpe announces a winner. If a qb is found and can play, the offense could be good with Victor Anderson running and Scott Long/Doug Beaumont receiving. The defense is in shambles. If they cannot find a way to gel it will be a long season. Road games against UConn, Cincy, WV and USF will make wins hard to come by.





