Recently, the SU blogosphere responded to an anonymous Post-Standard blog post about how the Orange have failed to lose a game despite some perceived shortcomings. Today, I hope to similarly serve you as a vigilante of SU hoops journalism.
In the years I’ve followed the Orange, Mookie Jones has been one of the most intriguing players to don a uniform, judging by the amount of discussion centered on the redshirt sophomore. Mookie excites, frustrates, amuses and confuses fans all at once with his three-point shooting ability, slowly developing defense and the occasional excessively public quote, whether it’s expressed through traditional media or Twitter or Facebook.
This morning, Ryan Day, who covers the ‘Cuse for the Auburn Citizen, penned a short commentary expressing his confusion over the clamoring for more Mookie this season. In it, he makes some valid points, but there are also a few spots where he slides a little off-base in his analysis. Let’s start right with the headline:
Not the right time for Mookie minutes
Looking at Syracuse’s schedule, with Drexel tonight followed by five of the Big East’s middle-to-lower tier squads – Providence, Notre Dame, Seton Hall, St. John’s and Cincinnati, it’s probably the best chance the team has left to get Jones rolling without a ton of risk. It’s certainly a better opportunity than the stretch that follows, when Syracuse plays at Pittsburgh, hosts Villanova and travels to UConn in a 15-day stretch. That span also includes a return trip from Seton Hall and a visit to Marquette, whose fans will be out in full force.
He’s a one-trick ponie — a 3-point shooter. He plays no defense and can’t do anything offensively other than shoot, and still, he hasn’t done that extraordinarily well.
I won’t jump on the equine misspelling from a journalist; I’d rather we just keep rolling here. Jones continues to be great at his one perceived skill – shooting the long ball. He’s connected on 41.7% of his three-pointers, not far removed from last season’s mark of 44.1% and his career line of 41.1%. If a 41% clip is not enough to characterize it as “extraordinarily well,” I’d love to get his take on Andy Rautins (37.4% lifetime) and Gerry McNamara (37.5%). On a team short on three-point shooters, Mookie’s accuracy has become a tool that this team desperately needs. At 102 career three-point attempts now in the books, the sample size has grown too large to dismiss.
And if you’re going to insert someone who’s a liability on defense, say a Dion Waiters, then be [sic] better be pretty terrific on offense. Well, Waiters is terrific on offense. And Mookie isn’t.
Six weeks ago, Waiters was a liability on defense, but since then, this assessment has started to become obsolete. Yes, Waiters draws a lot of attention to himself on offense with a great handle and flashy passes (even if some are ill-advised). As a freshman, he’s prone to the occasional defensive lapse, especially once conference play hits, but Waiters’ defense has improved dramatically since day one. Steals aren’t the end-all when it comes to locking down, but Waiters has totaled 15 of them in the Orange’s last nine games, and has at least one theft in each of those games. The timing for this criticism just seems off.
Granted, we haven’t seen Mookie do much of anything else on offense besides shoot the trey, but why imply that he needs more tools when the three guards in front of him on the depth chart can drive? The inside game, whether it comes from Jones’ teammates driving the lane or finishing in the post, is not an issue for this team. If we were talking about Mookie playing more than ten minutes per game, I would be a little more concerned, but I haven’t come across too many fans who are calling for Boeheim to give Jones that kind of run where he needs to have a more versatile game.
When asked why Mookie doesn’t play more, my answer is always the same: “Who do you want him playing over?”
Again, we aren’t talking about Mookie taking away major minutes. While teams have packed in the zone, he has the height at 6’6″ to maintain accuracy over taller defenders. That’s not the case with Scoop Jardine, and Brandon Triche has struggled with it as well. Between Kris Joseph and CJ Fair, there’s enough at the 3 that Mookie can stick to playing the two alongside either Jardine or Triche. For a short time against Morgan State, we got a look at a Dion-Mookie backcourt. Even with the understanding that SU was up by a blowout margin at that point, it was still unsightly. Play Mookie for two or three minutes at a time when Jardine or Triche need some rest and the team will be fine more often than not.
Syracuse’s biggest flaw this season is 3-point shooting, I grant you that. But it has yet to cost them. And when it does, I guarantee the calls for Mookie minutes will be even louder.
This seems to be as much as an indictment on Boeheim’s coaching appraoch as it is on the team’s three-point shooting ability. Failing to address a shortcoming before it’s too late is not part of Jim Boeheim’s MO, at least not in recent seasons. The closest scenario to the contrary I can picture was when I attended games as a student, prior to the resurgence that’s taken place over the last three seasons. I remember growing frustrated as an opposing player shot the lights out against Syracuse, and Boeheim wouldn’t even think about switching to man defense.
In my then-limited basketball knowledge, it bothered me that he would seemingly keep putting his hand on the stove despite getting burned, but he found a better solution that didn’t involve changing his patented coaching style. It was to simply recruit bigger, longer guards – guys like Andy Rautins, Brandon Triche and Dion Waiters. A major part of the game is making adjustments, but in recent seasons, Syracuse has been able to make those adjustments both in-game, as we saw when SU closed out on Morgan State’s Justin Black after he made a few threes, as well as on the recruiting trail. The results speak for themselves: In 2008-09, Syracuse ranked 8th in D-I in opponent 3G%. Last season, they were 22nd; this season, they’re 20th.
The Orange could still run into that proverbial hot three-point shooter who dooms the team, but SU has someone right on their bench who can do the same to the opposition, if only he’s afforded the chance.